How to Collect Customer Reviews on Your Website

by | Last Updated: Feb 20, 2023 | Featured, Marketing, Web Design |

Word of mouth has long been a powerful tool in getting new customers. Reviews are the new “word of mouth” referral system most relied upon by shoppers.

Research shows that 90% of consumers read online reviews before visiting a business, and 88% of consumers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations. Customers are likely to spend 31% more on a business’s “excellent” reviews, and 72% say that positive reviews make them trust a local company more.

In this article, I am going to show you why you should start collecting customer reviews, how you can start collecting reviews on your website. I am also going to run through the things to avoid when you are creating a reviews collection page.

Why You Should Start Collecting Customer Reviews

Customer Reviews Can Help Attract New Customers

Customer reviews are great for helping people make their buying decisions. Still, they’re also essential for building trust in a business. Look at it this way – if you’re a customer, which company would you prefer to do business with: one that has over 100 positive reviews or one that only has a few. Yep, it seems obvious, doesn’t it?

Consumers are far more likely to trust a business when they see reviews from people who have experienced positive things about your brand.

Enable Customers to Have a Voice and Create Loyalty.

Customers want to be able to speak directly to their suppliers. They want to be treated as individuals rather than as numbers in an accounting system. Reviews enables this direct customer connection. By allowing the customer to offer feedback directly, and by listening to them, the customer has a voice.

Consumers that spend the time to write a review for your business are far more likely to feel a loyalty to you and keep coming back. Especially if you respond and acknowledge their concerns when they arise.

People Are Doing Your Marketing for You

Think of it this way; each positive review is a tiny little marketing person working 24/7 on the internet on your behalf. Most positive reviews highlight the features and benefits they love most, helping the customer get familiar with the product before they even have to talk to someone in person or on the phone.

Studies show that 92% of users will use a local business if it has at least a 4-star rating, and 75% of consumers will take action only after reading a positive review. If applied strategically, collecting reviews is one of the best marketing tools in your arsenal.

How to Collect Customer Reviews

Now that we have covered the benefits of collecting online reviews and testimonials, let’s cover some of the practical ways to start collecting customer reviews on your website.

Make a Website Page Where You Can Collect Reviews

First, you need a place to collect reviews. Your customers may come to you via social media or a review site like Amazon. To collect those reviews, you will create a dedicated web page that’s easy for customers to share their feedback.

You will want to encourage them to submit reviews on popular third-party platforms such as Google, LinkedIn, Facebook, Yelp, Yellow Pages, and more. So you may want to include links to those pages as the preferred method to submit a review.

How to Collect Customer Reviews on Your Website - Collecting Reviews on Social Media

You can always include a form on the page that users can submit a review directly to you. Still, these external review platforms are vital as these are indexed in Google, and those backlinks to your site from these platforms can improve your SEO. You will also have a better chance of people finding your business and reviews online because of these platforms.

Make Your Page Easy to Share

This page should be easy for you to share with your customers after they’ve purchased. It’s important to make the URL easy to remember and share, such as

One of our favorite sharing plugins is the Monarch by Elegant Themes. Monarch is a premium plugin that allows the reader to share a website page or blog post on over 20+ Social Media channels. Monarch is free when you sign up for an Elegant Themes membership and is included for free with our monthly maintenance and hosting clients.

How to Collect Customer Reviews on Your Website - Download Monarch by Elegant Themes

What Goes on the Page?

It will help to keep this page as simple as possible. The easier it is for the customer to leave a review, the more likely they will. You can create a form that collects reviews directly or point people to websites where you collect reviews, such as Google, Facebook, Trustpilot, Yelp, etc.

These external review platforms are vital as these are indexed in Google, and those back-links to your site from these platforms can improve your SEO. You will also have a better chance of people finding your business and reviews online because of these platforms.

Things to Avoid When Collecting Customer Reviews

Review Gating

Review-gating is the process of making sure that only those who will provide a high-quality review will do so while screening out those who won’t give you any help at all.

Business owners are terrified of negative reviews and would love the opportunity only to have 5-star reviews; however, review gating is directly prohibited in Google My Businesses guidelines.

Not Having Clear Customer Feedback Goals

A common mistake is to assume that gathering feedback from customers is enough. However, most companies do not evaluate or apply the results. Without clearly defined goals, the feedback collected is likely to be unhelpful.

Failing to Show Respect and Courtesy for Your Customer’s Time

Decision makers have a lot on their plate and taking the time to write a thoughtful review can be an added burden to an already overwhelming schedule. An introductory line saying that you get it and appreciate that person’s time can go a long way in building rapport.

Forgetting to Show Appreciation

Thank your customers for the feedback they provided you. Showing that the customer’s feedback is valued by the people that will be affected by the review will make your customer feel even more appreciated!

Bonus Tips

Video Testimonials Are Very Effective

Another proven way to deliver more trust to potential customers is through video reviews and testimonials. ZipMessage is an example of a tool that you could use for this. ZipMessage facilitates a link that allows somebody to leave a video. They have several plans to choose from, including a free plan.

How to Collect Customer Reviews on Your Website - Sign up for Zipmessage

Display Reviews From Other Platforms On Your Website

If you are using WordPress for your website, you can use a plugin like WP Business Reviews that lets you add Yelp, Facebook, and Google reviews to WordPress. With this plugin, you can easily showcase your reviews from multiple platforms. You can choose to display reviews from all your platforms together or just one.

If you need something a little more robust, looks promising. While I have never used it before, I came across it while researching this topic and I think I will be giving it a try on my own website soon. I like that it has a number of popular networks to connect to and some of the feedback funnel options that come with the more expensive plans.

How to Collect Customer Reviews on Your Website - ReviewsOnMyWebsite.Com

In Closing

Asking a customer for a review or a testimonial can be a little nerve-wracking if you are not comfortable with criticism. Also, you don’t want to be pushy, but at the same time, it’s essential to get comments from your customers about your product or service. How will others know if you’re suitable for their company if you don’t?

You don’t need to do anything complex or spend time chasing every customer for a review. By following some of the guidelines listed here in this article, you will get more reviews from your customers and more sales thanks to all those new positive reviews.

Welcome to Building Community, the ultimate digital marketing and training hub for business owners and entrepreneurs like yourself. In today's fast-paced digital world, we understand the importance of staying connected and informed.

Recent Articles

Why Your Website Desperately Needs a Call to Action

Uncover the power of a website call to action in this comprehensive guide. Understand its importance, benefits, effective elements, and best practices. From driving user engagement to boosting sales, learn how a compelling CTA can transform your website’s performance.

Why Your New Site Doesn’t Show Up in Google Search Results

Discover why your new site isn’t showing up in Google search results and learn actionable steps to improve visibility through SEO, backlinks, and consistent monitoring. Boost your website’s online presence and traffic with this comprehensive guide.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Stay up to date with the latest news, products and services

You have Successfully Subscribed!

6 tips for preparing an accurate estimate image

Project Planning Tips for the Beginners and the Pros

Download our complimentary eBook that details 6 tips for preparing an accurate and profitable estimate for your web design project.

Success! Please check your inbox for an email from us.